Over this summer my work has been in the field of control theory. I must admit that I at first found it a little odd that the idea of “controlling something” — say, the temperature of a room or the speed of a fan — could be an extremely deep/rich mathematical and engineering discipline.
This series should hopefully be an enlightening walk through this wonderful world that is control theory, and explore (without any complex mathematics) just how much genius goes into those simple things we all take for granted.
Welcome to the Hamster Hotel.
The Hamster Hotel
You run a hamster hotel (a hotel for hamsters) and you have a problem. Elevators. Your hamster guests need to get from one story to another. They walk into the elevator, the elevator takes them to the right floor, and they walk off.
Due to an unfortunate mix-up on your contractor’s part, your only option is elevators operated via water jets (like the ones at water fountains). You can control how hard the jets push with a valve that you can open or shut partially. The water jets push little plates in chutes up, and the hamsters hitch along for a ride.
Let’s say you can control how much the valve is open by twisting a knob (kind of like a garden hose). The more open the valve is, the higher the jet goes and the higher the elevator car.
How do you find out how much you have to open the valve up to get the car to go exactly to the second story?
That’s Easy! (?)
Let’s try out some simple solutions. What would you do first?
Measure it out
The most straightforward solution would be to get a ruler and do some good ol’ empirical science-ing. You’ll open the valve until you get to each floor. Then, you’ll write down the amount that you’ve twisted the knob (10%, 20%?). Then, whenever you want to go to a floor, you’ll look it up on your table, twist the knob to the corresponding value, and hamsters rejoice!
Time to do this. Ground floor? 0% twisted open. Second floor? 3%. Third floor? 12%. Fourth floor? 27%. To get to the roof, you need to only set it to 48% open.
Now that you have completely science’d the situation, it’s time to start using your elevator. You load up a hamster for the inaugural ride.
The Plight of the Hamster
First problem. With a hamster actually inside the elevator, the whole thing is heavier, and a 3% open valve just doesn’t cut it anymore to get it up even one story. You find out that have to crank it up to 5%. Third floor now takes a 20% opened valve.
This is a disaster! Not only is your valued guest disappointed, but this fiasco has also rendered the entire first percentages table useless. You might try to change the table to account for one hamster. But what if your guest takes along also the missus as well? Should we keep two tables – one for a one-hamster car, and one for a two-hamster car?
But we musn’t stereotype — hamsters all have different weights. And what if the guests had luggage? Maybe we can measure the luggage, and create a new table for every possible total weight combination?
What if one day the water pressure of the water jet drops, so less water comes out when the knob is twisted? Do you have to remeasure everything all over again?
Clearly, there must be a better way.
You just graduated with your bachelor’s degree in Physics. You know all about the laws governing force, gravity, water, pressure, potential energy, friction, turbulence, hamster physiology … all of that stuff. You memorized all of the equations, because that’s what Physics is all about, right?1
So, you whip out your precious equations (which you hold to be worth at least the $200,000 you spent to learn them). Sure enough, you have enough equations in your tool belt to describe and model the physical system almost perfectly. There are some constants you need to figure out — the friction in the shaft, for example, or the width of your pipes — and after that, given the weight of the load, the water pressure per degree of knob twist (which may change depending on the day), the desired height, the ambient room temperature, the heat of the elevator shaft, the temperature inside the pipes, the current air pressure, the humidity, the state of the lubrication in the shaft … you can predict exactly how much you need to twist that water knob.
You write a little program on your TI-89 to calculate the right amount of twist for all of those parameters, and you are good to go!
Does Not Compute
You see where the flaw in the plan is?
Of course: it’s very rude to ask a hamster for her weight!
Also, aside from that, there are just too many parameters you have to constantly monitor, measure, and maintain. If you don’t get it all exactly right, your hamsters are likely to get stuck inside somehow. Certainly not the path to gaining a five star reputation!
Even if you somehow managed to find all of the proper parameters to a “good enough” level every time … in general, it’s unrealistic to expect to be able to derive an analytic solution to all of your problems.
All these things aside, there are even graver issues that plague this system.
What if the parameters change in mid-trip? What if the water pressure suddenly dropped? What if the lubrication was different along the length of the shaft? What if a hamster jumps onto the car last-minute?
Certainly if any of these things happened, our poor hamster guests would undoubtedly fall straight to their doom.
The problem with this system is that it’s simply not dynamic.
Sure, you could make a model that accounts for all of the changes possible, but is that really practical?
For a genius the likes of which the world has never seen, it may be possible.
But … there has to be a better way.